December 26, 2006 10:46 pm
Uneven Stevens
Posted by Will under writing
Got home to find a voicemail message from an editor at the Times, calling to confirm I was indeed a writer of a recent letter to the editor signed by me and telling me they’re interested in running it some time this week.
I’d forgotten all about the letter, being one that I whipped off last Friday Thursday morning after reading a puff brief on a performance last week by Yusuf Islam, which mentioned his most recent 2004 controversy but somehow ignored the much bigger one he stoked the year my daughter was born:
I grew up adoring the music of Yusuf Islam back when he was called Cat Stevens, but that adoration abruptly ended in 1989 when he publicly supported calls by Iran’s Ayatollah Khomeini for the assassination of author Salman Rushdie who allegedly blasphemed the Muslim religion in his novel “The Satanic Verses.” Thus I found it interesting in Ellen Wulfhorst’s review of Islam’s performance this week (”Older, wiser and back aboard ‘Peace Train,’” Calendar Weekend, December 21) that his 2004 “no-fly list” controversy was mentioned, but not this far more disturbing public position.
In recent years, such as with this U.S. performance, the former superstar has attempted to mitigate the damage to his career and spin-manage his stance but the fact is he hoped for the death of the writer and said he would willingly help bring it about if he could, and to me that will forever derail whatever “peace train” he tries to get aboard.
Will Campbell
Los Angeles
Am I grudge-hugging too hard? Nope. This man and his music were inspirations to me and I wasn’t exagerating when I wrote of my adoration of him. His little ditty “If You Want To Sing Out, Sing Out,” which I first heard as a teen in the film “Harold and Maude” was like a revelatory scriptural anthem to me and there’s nothing that can reconcile the shock and betrayal I felt with his blatant support for Rushdie’s destruction. I simply can’t listen to anything of his now without it being clouded, and certainly won’t suffer his weak explanations of how what he said back then was misinterpreted or taken out of context.


December 27th, 2006 at 12:35 pm
Guess MY letter on the toipic didn’t make THE TIMES… Here it is…
At a musical “showcase” (meaning: free tickets, invited guests) in New York City, Yusuf Islam, formerly known as “Cat Stevens”, says he was barred from entry into the US because of a “spelling error” (Calendar, 12-21, E5). Had The Times done the least bit of fact-checking, you would have found that he was most likely refused entry into America because of his ringing endorsement of the “fatwa”, or death sentence, issued in 1989 by the Ayatollah Khomeini against the author Salman Rushdie for the supposed “crime” of criticizing the Koran and/or the Muslim religion’s founder, Mohammed. Any artist who supports the blacklisting and even death of another does not understand the nature of art or artistic freedom. For “Calendar” to feature a story on Yusuf Islam’s attempted professional comeback without noting his support (never retracted) of the call for the death of a fellow artist is an egregious, dangerous mistake.
Kudos to you, my man!
Steve Parker
December 27th, 2006 at 1:29 pm
Thanks Steve! Glad to read I’m not the only one who feels this way.