January 15, 2007 7:21 pm
Fact v. Fiction: The Thing With 24
Posted by Will under television, updated
So Keifer Sutherland’s Jack Bauer got going last night with the first of a two-part, four-hour premiere of the new season of “24,” and man am I glad Jack’s back in town. Sure, I know the program is just one big live-action comic book that can stretch the suspension of my disbelief well beyond its breaking point, but I just roll with it. Mostly.
The show’s inconsistencies that wind up sticking in my craw are miniscule to be sure — immaterial even — but they stick out large. Like…
1) In the first hour I found it very interesting that the president can authorize an airstrike delivered via two missile-bearing assault helicopters that successfully blow up a Los Angeles house killing all the occupants without so much as a neighbor saying WTF or witnesses capturing video of the attack on their cellphones. And let’s just nevermind that there are no supporting ground forces onhand at the time of the missile launch to prevent anyone’s escape.
2) Also in the first hour a man breaks and enters a house and threatens a resident because the lunkhead believes he’s a terr’ist, of course. This is witnessed by neighbors who intervene and break things up, but no one calls and reports the crime to the cops so that this lunkhead gets arrested. Of course later in the second hour the lunkhead returns to break and enter again this time aggravatedly assaulting the resident with intent to cause great bodily harm. Lunkhead’s doing quite well with that bodily harm part, but fortunately for the guy the lunkhead is beating up he actually is a terrorist and is able to kill the lunkhead with the help of a nearby pistol.
3) Then in the second hour my man Jack, while tailing a soon-to-be suicide bomber, finds himself on an MTA Red Line subway train heading to Union Station with said bomber. And what to my wondering eyes should magically appear from out of nowhere? Nothing less than a uniformed MTA conductor checking tickets with some sort of scanning device. Of course the ticketman asks Jack for his ticket (which Jack does not have) thus Jack has to inform the man that he’s a federal agent surveilling a man with a bomb so the ticketman better damn well leave him alone and act like nothing’s happened, which this suddenly wide-eyed MTA conductor does, ultimately allowing my hero Jack to wrestle with the bomber and eventually kick him out the car’s back door and onto the tracks just prior to bomb going boom thereby saving himself, the make-believe conductor, the passengers and the train. Let’s just nevermind that rather than the caboose, a suicide bomber would get in a far more forward car where the detonation might have a better chance of causing a deraillment and thus much more damage.
I know I shouldn’t let a little thing like reality get in the way of my enjoyment — and in fact, I don’t. But still, the reality is that there are no uniformed MTA conductors traveling through its subway and light-rail cars checking tickets. Presently I believe the L.A. County Sheriffs Department is the law enforcement agency the MTA contracts to provide security and also spot-check — very randomly — for tickets. And they don’t use any type of digital scanning devices.
But of course, had the writers not taken liberties and Jack had been forced to try that “I’m a federal agent, just move along like everything’s OK” shtick with an armed deputy that wouldn’t have worked out so well and the bomber would have then succeeded in blowing up Jack and the deputies and the bystanders and the train car. And then the series would be over.
Or it could’ve just been written different. Have Jack subdue the deputy or somehow convince him to help. Have the bomber’s bomb malfunction. Or have the bomb detonate and Jack survive it. Or have Jack kicked out the back of the train by the bomber who then blows himself up as Jack helplessly watches the train receding deeper into the tunnel away from him.
Or I’ll just shut up now because part two is on in a few minutes and I can’t wait to see what happens. Even if it pisses me off.
UPDATED (10:13 p.m.): Which it did: Double dang if in the first hour Keifer doesn’t have Jack Bauer say “noo-kyoo-lur.”


January 15th, 2007 at 8:42 pm
I kind of dismissed #3. I figure after 900 people have been killed on bombing attacks on public transportation the ticketing policing might be a bit different than it is in our world.
However, kicking the fellow out the back window … which shattered … was implausible.
I got the impression from the plot that the bomber wasn’t supposed to explode himself on that train, he was supposed to do something at the station … but maybe I’m giving the show too much credit.
(I thought Jack being embarassed by his scars was a little odd. I also wondered how he stayed in good shape if he was starved and tortured … or maybe all that writhing and spasming of torture is a good ab workout.)
January 15th, 2007 at 10:20 pm
I can see your point about accepting changes in ticket policing policy in light of the rash of attacks… but all the more that there should have been a deputy there and not just some dude in an MTA shirt.
And now that yo umention it I think you’re right about the bomber planning on blowing himself up at Union Station and not on the train.
January 17th, 2007 at 12:25 pm
I saw an MTA conductor - two of them, working together - once on the Blue Line into Long Beach. They boarded, asked everyone for tickets and chastised a guy for suggestively holding an open box of candy. “Yer not sellin’ that candy on mah train, are ya?”
January 17th, 2007 at 3:56 pm
Interesting, AVN. I wonder if that’s some sort of Blue Line deal because in all the times I’ve rode all manner and color of MTA’s rails and especially on the subway, the only ticket-check encounters I’ve witnessed have been with uniformed law enforcement personnel.
January 18th, 2007 at 7:49 pm
Oh, and the magic cell phones! Don’t forget the magic cell phones! They’re everywhere, just when you need them, and they can do *anything*, including receiving and making calls at the same time.
But my favorite part was how Chloe was able to remotely recover data off a blown up hard drive within a couple minutes of the explosion. I figure the magic cell phones must has some kind of magic scanning device which can read the bytes off a destroyed drive and beam them *very* quickly to CTU.